Calculus: implicit differentiation, part 2: verification
Tutoring calculus, implicit differentiation is a celebrated topic. The tutor mentions some top-down verification.
The following is by my understanding.
I mention implicit differentiation in my post from Jan 22, 2015. It’s a way to take the derivative when the dependent variable isn’t isolated.
Yet, sometimes one might wonder, “Can I believe this is really working?” A way to verify it works in one case might be with the circle x2 + y2 = 25.
Using implicit differentiation, one arrives at dy/dx = -x/y. Then, looking at the circle graph, which is centered at (0,0) with points (0,5), (0,-5), (5,0), (-5,0), one can pop in a few points to see if the slope makes sense at them.
At (0,5), the derivative, i.e. the slope, is -x/y = -(0)/5 = 0, which makes sense looking at the graph as described above. At (5,0), -x/y would be undefined, which once again the graph suggests.
Next, it seems (5/√2,5/√2) is also on the graph, suggesting a slope of -(5/√2)/(5/√2) = -1 at that point. Looking at the graph, one can see that makes sense.
I find it’s often helpful to verify results in math where possible.
Source:
Larson,R.E., Hostetler,R.P. (1989). Calculus, part one, third edition. D.C. Heath and Company.
Jack of Oracle Tutoring by Jack and Diane, Campbell River, BC.